September 18, 2009
By Chris Brooke
Common sense should have warned Robert Jones that this narrow cliffside path was no place for a BMW but, with his satellite navigation system shrilly insisting it was the way, he just kept driving.
Then the car nosed into a fence and became stuck perilously close to a 30m drop.
Jones, 43, was found guilty of driving without due care and attention. He is thought to be the first person punished for slavishly following a satnav’s orders.
The car was eventually towed to safety in a recovery operation costing the equivalent of about R12 500, lasting nine hours and involving a tractor and three quads
‘He followed the system to the letter’ – prosecutor
.
Jones, who delivers cars across Britain for a living, was fined the equivalent of R4620, ordered to pay R6250 costs and had six penalty points put on his licence. In total, his faith in his satnav left him about R25 000 out of pocket.
His accidental off-road adventure happened in March, 2009 as he drove through Todmorden in West Yorkshire, England.
“The defendant was using a TomTom satellite navigation system,” Waseem Raja, prosecuting, told Calderdale magistrates. “He followed that system to the letter, so much so, it led him up a lane clearly unsuitable for motor vehicles.
“The path was not designed for motor vehicles yet he slavishly continued to follow the satnav system to the point where his eyes and his brain must have been telling him he was not exercising proper control of the vehicle
‘I had no reason not to trust it’ – Jones
.”
Jones, of Doncaster in Yorkshire, was driving home after visiting friends when he got into trouble. With his fuel gauge indicating he had only 10km of petrol left, he was desperate to find a fuel station.
He turned down what the satnav suggested was a road. Despite it becoming apparent that he was on a dirt track he “trusted” his TomTom and continued. Three kilometres later he ended up far too close to a cliff edge.
“I might have been an idiot for taking the wrong road or carrying on but I have not driven without due care or attention,” he told the court.
Jones, who had been using the satnav system for three months, added: “I drive 8000km a week and I’ve never have had a problem with it. I had no reason not to trust it.”
‘YOU’RE THE BOSS, NOT THE SATNAV’
He had to walk to the nearest village to phone for help because his cellphone battery was dead. The AA told him to ring the emergency services and he eventually paid a local recovery firm to pull him clear using a 4×4 vehicle.
Constable Stephen Young, the traffic officer called to the scene, said the farmer who owned the land told him he would not even take his horses down that path.
Outside the court Jones said: “I was using the satnav properly but users should be made more aware they should only use them as a guide. In a sense I feel silly but I’m disgusted how many points have been put on my licence as I see what happened as an innocent accident.
“People who drive without insurance get smaller penalties.”
Kevin Clinton, of the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents, said: “Driving requires concentration and focus and road users should remember that they are the boss, not the satnav.” – Daily Mail